ILS Legal Monitor

First Amendment · Section 230 · AI Liability

Nerdy Skynet!

March 17, 2026

Coverage: 2026-03-13 through 2026-03-17   ·   1 new development this period

Commentary & Analysis 1 item

Techdirt

Ninth Circuit Guts California’s Kids Code Once Again

Techdirt  · 2026-03-14

Commentary

The Ninth Circuit struck down key provisions of California's Age Appropriate Design Code (AADC) as unconstitutionally vague under the First Amendment, holding that terms like "best interests of children," "well-being," and "materially detrimental" are insufficiently clear standards for regulating how platforms handle content and data for minors. The court found these provisions, though framed as privacy protections, actually functioned as content-based speech restrictions that lack the definitional clarity required by the First Amendment. The ruling follows the procedural framework established by SCOTUS's Moody v. NetChoice decision, which raised the bar for facial constitutional challenges.

Key point: The Ninth Circuit invalidated California's attempt to regulate platform design and content curation for minors by requiring operations in children's "best interests," finding the standards unconstitutionally vague and functionally content-regulatory despite their privacy-law framing.

Read post →

Sources: CourtListener API  ·  All 13 federal circuit RSS feeds  ·  All 50 state supreme courts + intermediate appellate courts (8 states) via Justia  ·  Eric Goldman  ·  Techdirt
 Generated automatically. Next edition in approximately 3–4 days. 

Unsubscribe